khanikoff

Updated: May 27, 2025

General Ferrier, who resided for some time in Herat, in 1846, states that the city is nothing more than an immense redoubt, and gives it as his opinion that, as the line of wall is entirely without flanking defences, the place could not hold out for twenty days against a European army; and M. Khanikoff, who, although not a professional soldier, was a very acute observer, further remarks that the whole interior of the city is dominated from the rising ground 700 yards distant and covered with solid buildings at the northeast angle, while the water supply both for the ditch and the city would be at the mercy of an enemy holding the outside country; the wells and reservoirs inside the wall, which could then alone be available being quite inadequate to the wants of the inhabitants: but on the other hand, all experience testifies to the defensibility of the position.

Theo. F. Rodenbough - Afghanistan and the Anglo-Russian Dispute